·读者提出“艾滋女”六大疑点


·读者提出“艾滋女”六大疑点

2010年04月16日12:38合肥在线
字号:T|T
 

  合肥晚报讯 连日来省城多家媒体关注的“艾滋女”事件自发帖人被拘留后似乎落下帷幕,但不少细心读者还是从中品出不同味道:发帖人被拘不代表事情结束。按照不少读者观点,目前尚有六大疑点亟待澄清。

  1.“春兰”到底是何身份?

  无论是89个号码中间部分机主所言,还是记者从知情人处获悉,“春兰”极有可能从事色情服务。据悉,这也是赵发帖原因之一。

  2.“春兰”是否患有艾滋病?

  现在,造谣者抓住了,但对这个谜,警方相关负责人称:“(是否是艾滋)鉴定程序复杂,要三个月以后才能得出结果,而且涉及当事人隐私,不便公布。”

  3.“春兰”两个女儿是何身份?

  按理说,找到报案人,查明她的身份不是难事,但很遗憾,记者询问了相关人士,却没有得到关于“春兰”女儿近况的任何消息。

  4.89个号码到底怎么回事?

  据赵承认,89个号码源自“春兰”的手机。多家媒体记者先后多次和机主取得联系,甚至有媒体将所有号码一一拨打,竟然有近10人承认曾和“春兰”有过密切往来,还有两三人坦承和她发生过性关系。那这到底怎么回事?

  5.为何是拘留8天?

  行政拘留而不是刑事拘留,被关8天而不是3年,原因何在?金先生看了报道,仔细将本案和闫德利案进行了对比,发现有不少有意思的细节。“就目前而言,两案性质相同,都是发帖人为了报复对方而捏造事实进行诽谤,影响同样恶劣。但闫德利案,发帖人被判入狱三年,而本案赵某仅关8天,反差之大令人惊奇。”

  6.当事网站有无责任?

  赵某首先在网站论坛发帖,在网络引起轰动后才引起传统媒体跟进,而查证结果子虚乌有,所涉网站论坛有无责任?律师出身的贾先生认为,此事无中生有网站逃不了干系。据称,去年12月全国人大通过的《侵权责任法》确立规则,即“网络服务提供者知道网络用户利用其网络服务侵害他人民事权益,未采取必要措施的,与该网络用户承担连带责任”。

  “艾滋女”事件何时才能水落石出,本报将继续关注。 (占金兵)

2010年04月16日12:38合肥在线 字号:T|T
合肥晚报讯连日来省城多家媒体关注的“艾滋女”事件自发帖人被拘留后似乎落下帷幕,但不少细心读者还是从中品出不同味道:发帖人被拘不代表事情结束。
按照不少读者观点,目前尚有六大疑点亟待澄清。

  1.“春兰”到底是何身份?

无论是89个号码中间部分机主所言,还是记者从知情人处获悉,“春兰”极有可能从事色情服务。
据悉,这也是赵发帖原因之一。

  2.“春兰”是否患有艾滋病?

现在,造谣者抓住了,但对这个谜,警方相关负责人称:“(是否是艾滋)鉴定程序复杂,要三个月以后才能得出结果,而且涉及当事人隐私,不便公布。”

  3.“春兰”两个女儿是何身份?

按理说,找到报案人,查明她的身份不是难事,但很遗憾,记者询问了相关人士,却没有得到关于“春兰”女儿近况的任何消息。

  4.89个号码到底怎么回事?

据赵承认,89个号码源自“春兰”的手机。多家媒体记者先后多次和机主取得联系,甚至有媒体将所有号码一一拨打,竟然有近10人承认曾和“春兰”有过密切往来,还有两三人坦承和她发生过性关系。
那这到底怎么回事?

  5.为何是拘留8天?

行政拘留而不是刑事拘留,被关8天而不是3年,原因何在?金先生看了报道,仔细将本案和闫德利案进行了对比,发现有不少有意思的细节。 “就目前而言,两案性质相同,都是发帖人为了报复对方而捏造事实进行诽谤,影响同样恶劣。但闫德利案,发帖人被判入狱三年,而本案赵某仅关8
天,反差之大令人惊奇。”

  6.当事网站有无责任?

赵某首先在网站论坛发帖,在网络引起轰动后才引起传统媒体跟进,而查证结果子虚乌有,所涉网站论坛有无责任?律师出身的贾先生认为,此事无中生有网站逃不了干系。据称,去年12月全国人大通过的《侵权责任法》确立规则,即“网络服务提供者知道网络用户利用其网络服务侵害他人民事权益,未采取必要措施的,与该网络用户承担连带责任”


“艾滋女”事件何时才能水落石出,本报将继续关注。
(占金兵)
* Readers that "AIDS girl" Six doubt
At 12:38 on April 16, 2010, Hefei online font size: T | T
The provincial capital Hefei Evening News over the past few days of media attention, "AIDS girl" incident had been detained since the post appears after the curtain falls, but many careful readers, or a different flavor from products: Posted by detainees does not mean the end of things. In accordance with the number of readers point of view, there are six urgent need to clarify doubts.

1. "Chunlan" in the end of the identity?

89 numbers, whether the middle of Main said, or reporter was informed from the insider, "Chunlan" may engage in sexual services. It is reported that Zhao is one of the reasons posted.

2. "Chunlan" is suffering from AIDS?

Now, acting in grasp, but this mystery, the responsible person the police: "(whether HIV) identification procedures are complicated and the results to be obtained after three months, but the parties involved in the privacy of public inconvenience."

3. "Chunlan" two daughters of the identity?

It stands to reason, locate the victim, her identity not be difficult to identify, but unfortunately, the reporter asked about the stakeholders have not been on the "Chunlan" Recent daughter to any news.

4.89 No matter how in the end?

According to Zhao acknowledged that 89 numbers from "Chunlan" phone. Number of media owners with a number of occasions and get in touch, and even the media will call all the numbers one by one, yet there are nearly 10 people admitted and "Chunlan" had close contacts, there are two or three people admitted had sex with her relations. This is how it happened in the end?

5. Why is the detention of eight days?

Administrative detention rather than criminal detention, being held eight days instead of 3 years, why not? Mr. King read the report carefully to the case and Yan Deli cases were compared and found many interesting details. "For now, the two cases of the same nature, are posted in retaliation for the other person and fabricating facts to slander, the same bad effect. But the case of Yan Deli, Posted by imprisonment for three years, while Zhao case related only 8 days, great amazing contrast. "

6. Party website with or without responsibility?

Zhao first website posting, caused a sensation in the network after the cause of traditional media to follow up the results of verifying non-existent, the Web forums with or without responsibility? Lawyer, Mr. Jia that this fictitious website run away dry lines. Alleged that in December last year, the NPC adopted the "Tort Liability Act" establishes the rule that "network service provider that network users to use their network service infringes upon civil rights, not take the necessary measures, and jointly and severally liable to the network users" .

"HIV Women" event when we can get to the bottom, this newspaper will continue to pay attention. (Accounting for Kinbyo)
 
 
 
 
 

[ 作者:佚名    转贴自:本站原创    点击数:196    更新时间:2010-4-16    文章录入:nnb ]